Spurred largely by the pandemic, the direct-to-consumer (D2C) business model (sometimes called DTC) experienced exponential growth. This enabled brands to establish a direct connection with consumers, bypassing traditional retail channels. However, the landscape is shifting, and signs suggest that the once seemingly invincible DTC model may no longer be sustainable in its current form. A recent CNBC article purported that many once successful D2C brands are now struggling, and “…more than half have seen a decline of 50% or more in their stock price since they went public.” Why the change and what does this mean for the once profitable vertical? And more importantly, how can EDI integration solve these challenges?
Table of Contents
- What is a D2C Business Model?
- Nine Challenges of the D2C Business Model
- How to Solve D2C Business Model Challenges with EDI Integration
What is a D2C Business Model?
The Direct-to-Consumer (D2C) business model refers to brands selling their products directly to customers. This means bypassing traditional intermediaries such as wholesalers, retailers, or distributors. Core principles of D2C include direct customer engagement, control over the brand experience, and the ability to gather valuable customer data.
Unlike traditional retail models, D2C businesses cut out the middlemen, enabling them to retain more profit and build stronger relationships with their customers. They also differ from third-party distribution channels like online marketplaces, as D2C brands maintain full control over pricing, marketing, and customer service.
Some examples of successful D2C brands include:
-
- Warby Parker: Revolutionizing the eyewear industry by offering affordable, stylish glasses directly to consumers. They are known for their exclusive try-on-at-home program.
- Glossier: A beauty brand that built a cult following through digital-first marketing and direct customer sales. Glossier targets their cruelty-free, customized, clean beauty to Millennials and Gen Zs, who are known for supporting mission-based brands.
- Casper: A mattress company known for its innovative approach to selling high-quality sleep products online. This company has seen a lot of success with social media influencers.
Nine Challenges of the D2C Business Model
1. Logistics and Supply Chain Management
When a product company also becomes their own technology and logistics company, then business trails off, they now have this IT and logistics infrastructure eating holes in their cash flow. Managing the entire supply chain, from production to distribution, is a complex task for DTC brands. Many have struggled to scale efficiently, facing logistical challenges and increased operational costs. The need for robust infrastructure and efficient supply chain management is becoming a stumbling block for the sustainability of the DTC model. The DTC business model has not evolved from a supply chain technology standpoint. Where electronic data interchange (EDI) integration has been the backbone of supply chain for the last 40 years, DTC is still relying on difficult-to-integrate webstores with no standardization in site.
EDI helps streamline complex logistics workflows. By automating data exchanges between suppliers, manufacturers, and logistics providers, EDI ensures that information flows seamlessly across the supply chain. This reduces the likelihood of errors, enhances visibility, and enables D2C brands to better respond to demand fluctuations or supply chain disruptions. With EDI, businesses can optimize inventory levels, improve delivery times, and achieve a level of operational efficiency that would be difficult to replicate with manual processes.
2. Technology Integration Gaps
Ensuring seamless data flow between sales, inventory, and customer systems is a persistent challenge for many D2C brands. The lack of standardized integrations between webstores and internal systems creates inefficiencies and data discrepancies that can disrupt operations. Non-standardized platforms often require custom solutions that are time-consuming and expensive to implement, making it difficult to achieve a cohesive technological ecosystem.
Tailored EDI solutions ensure data consistency across platforms by standardizing communication between disparate systems. EDI acts as a central hub for data exchange, bridging the gaps between sales, inventory, and customer systems. By automating these processes, EDI eliminates the need for manual data transfers, reduces errors, and enables real-time synchronization. This integration ensures all systems operate in harmony, enhancing operational efficiency and enabling seamless customer experiences.
3. Data Accuracy and Visibility
For D2C brands, maintaining data accuracy is critical to avoiding costly mistakes like order errors or overstocking. Lack of visibility into real-time inventory levels or order statuses can lead to miscommunication, delayed deliveries, and customer dissatisfaction. Errors in order processing can also result in chargebacks and strained relationships with suppliers or logistics partners.
Real-time EDI data exchange minimizes human error by automating the flow of information across the supply chain. EDI systems provide up-to-date visibility into inventory levels, order progress, and shipment statuses, enabling D2C brands to make data-driven decisions quickly. By reducing manual data entry and ensuring consistent data accuracy, EDI helps businesses optimize operations, avoid costly mistakes, and improve overall customer satisfaction.
4. Scalability Concerns
As D2C businesses grow, their operational demands increase exponentially. Adapting systems to handle rapid growth often exposes gaps in infrastructure, leading to disruptions in service and reduced efficiency. Without flexible systems in place, businesses risk being unable to scale effectively, which can hinder their ability to expand into new markets or manage increased demand.
EDI scales alongside your business for consistent performance, offering the flexibility needed to support growth. Whether expanding product lines or entering international markets, EDI systems can handle larger transaction volumes and accommodate new trading partners seamlessly. This scalability ensures that operational workflows remain stable, allowing businesses to focus on strategic growth initiatives without being bogged down by technical limitations.
5. Saturation & Competition
The DTC space has become oversaturated with new entrants trying to capitalize on the model’s success. As more brands flood the market with influencers on TikTok and Instagram Reels, competition intensifies, making it increasingly challenging for businesses to stand out and acquire new customers. The cost of customer acquisition rises, and smaller players may find it difficult to compete against DTC established brands like Ruggable, Casper and Warby Parker.
EDI solutions improve backend efficiency, allowing brands to focus on differentiation. By streamlining supply chain operations and automating routine tasks, EDI frees up resources that can be redirected towards building unique value propositions and engaging marketing strategies. This enables brands to focus on what makes them stand out in a crowded marketplace, such as superior customer experiences or innovative products.
6. Rising Customer Acquisition Costs
Initially heralded for its cost-effectiveness, the DTC model is now facing a significant challenge in the form of escalating customer acquisition costs. As competition heats up, brands are forced to spend more on marketing, advertising, and promotions to capture the attention of potential customers. This undermines the model’s profitability and raises questions about its long-term viability. Meanwhile, marketplaces continue to grow by leaps and bounds. According to Forbes, the behemoth Amazon continues to grow an average of 8.5% year-over-year.
Reducing backend inefficiencies with EDI helps offset rising acquisition costs. EDI streamlines operational workflows, allowing businesses to allocate more resources to customer acquisition strategies without sacrificing efficiency. Additionally, by enhancing the overall customer experience through faster order processing and reliable delivery, EDI fosters repeat business and strengthens brand loyalty, reducing the need for continuous spending on customer acquisition.
7. Consumer Fatigue & Loyalty Concerns
Consumers are bombarded with an overwhelming number of DTC options, leading to decision fatigue. With so many choices, brand loyalty becomes elusive, as consumers may switch between brands easily. This lack of loyalty poses a threat to the sustainability of the DTC model, as repeat business is essential for long-term success. Gone are the days of toy and cereal commercials on Saturday mornings. In 2024, brands must be much more clever for the savvy consumers buying today. When you can skip ads on premium streaming services, you must look for new ways to reach your audience!
Operational excellence via EDI frees up resources for customer engagement. With supply chain processes automated and optimized, brands can focus on building stronger relationships with their customers. Personalized marketing campaigns, loyalty programs, and enhanced customer support become more feasible when operational resources are freed from manual logistics management. This helps brands cultivate lasting customer loyalty in an increasingly competitive market.
8. Marketplace Dominance & Retail Resurgence
E-commerce giants and marketplace platforms have established dominance in the online retail space. The convenience of same day delivery and free returns, coupled with vast product offerings provided by these platforms, are diverting consumers away from DTC brands. Additionally, traditional retailers are adapting to the digital landscape, offering BOPIS (buy online pick up in store), challenging the exclusivity that DTC brands once enjoyed. Behind the scenes of course is EDI integration, which offers stability and efficiency to the supply chain – something still elusive to the DTC model.
EDI solutions help D2C brands achieve marketplace-level efficiency. By automating data exchanges and standardizing communication between supply chain partners, EDI enables D2C brands to match the operational precision of marketplace giants. This includes faster order processing, real-time inventory updates, and reliable fulfillment, all of which contribute to a seamless customer experience that rivals larger competitors.
9. Regulatory Challenges
As the DTC model gained popularity, regulators started paying closer attention. Compliance with various regulations, especially regarding data privacy and advertising practices with the popularity of social media, has become a significant concern. Navigating these regulatory hurdles adds another layer of complexity for DTC brands, potentially affecting their ability to operate smoothly. A new layer of complexity is the recent popularity of artificial intelligence (AI). Any speculation at this point on how AI will affect regulatory issues in the near future is just that, but sooner or later – it is coming.
EDI supports compliance by providing accurate, auditable data exchange. EDI systems create a transparent and standardized record of all transactions, making compliance with data privacy, tax, and other regulatory requirements easier. By automating the reporting and documentation processes, EDI reduces the risk of non-compliance and simplifies audits, ensuring that businesses stay ahead of evolving regulations while maintaining operational integrity.
How to Solve D2C Business Model Challenges with EDI Integration
Electronic Data Interchange (EDI) is the digital exchange of business documents in a standardized format between trading partners. By integrating EDI into their operations, D2C businesses can streamline processes, reduce errors, and enhance overall efficiency. Here’s how:
- Streamlined Inventory Management EDI enables real-time communication between D2C brands and their suppliers. Automated stock level updates and inventory reports help businesses maintain optimal inventory levels, reducing the risk of overstocking or stockouts.
- Efficient Order Processing With EDI, order processing is automated, minimizing manual data entry errors. Orders are transmitted directly to suppliers or fulfillment centers in a standardized format, speeding up the order-to-delivery cycle.
- Improved Supply Chain Coordination EDI fosters seamless communication between all supply chain stakeholders. Purchase orders, shipping notices, and invoices can be exchanged in real time, reducing delays and ensuring alignment across the supply chain.
- Enhanced Customer Experience By leveraging EDI, D2C businesses can provide customers with real-time updates on order status and shipping. Additionally, returns and exchanges can be managed more efficiently, boosting customer satisfaction.
- Scalability and Flexibility EDI systems are designed to handle large transaction volumes, making it easier for D2C businesses to scale operations. Whether entering new markets or managing seasonal demand spikes, EDI ensures seamless operations.
Step 1: Identify Core Operational Gaps
Pinpoint inefficiencies in data and logistics workflows. Start by analyzing current processes to identify bottlenecks, redundancies, or manual tasks that can be automated with EDI. Understanding these gaps lays the foundation for successful integration and improved efficiency.
Step 2: Choose a Trusted EDI Partner
Partner with providers like GraceBlood to ensure robust and reliable EDI implementation. A trusted partner will offer tailored solutions, industry expertise, and ongoing support to meet your unique business needs.
Step 3: Implement Technology Integration
Ensure seamless connectivity across platforms. Integrate your EDI solution with existing systems such as ERP, CRM, and warehouse management software to create a unified operational ecosystem. This ensures smooth data flow and reduces the risk of errors.
Step 4: Plan for Scalability
Build infrastructure capable of supporting long-term growth. Your EDI system should be flexible enough to handle increased transaction volumes, new trading partners, and market expansions without compromising performance.
Step 5: Monitor and Optimize Performance
Use data analytics for continuous improvement. Regularly review key performance metrics to identify areas for optimization. This includes tracking order accuracy, processing times, and supply chain efficiency to ensure your EDI system evolves with your business needs.
D2C Business Model Has Its Work Cut Out
While the direct-to-consumer DTC business model has played a pivotal role in reshaping the retail landscape, its current sustainability is under scrutiny. As challenges mount, from increased competition to technology challenges (lack of EDI integration) and changing consumer behaviors, DTC brands must evolve to stay relevant. Whether through strategic partnerships, diversification, or innovative solutions to address supply chain issues, the future success of DTC brands hinges on their ability to adapt to a shifting market landscape. Additionally, DTC brands must demand that their technology vendors offer the means to connect disparate systems in order to leverage the efficiency of EDI and data integration.
If you’re struggling with EDI integration, speak to one of our experts and end the struggle, once and for all.
